For ninety years the State of Idaho had owned scattered pieces of Arbon Valley and rented them out to whoever farmed beside them. On the afternoon of Friday, February 27, 1981, some of that ground was to be sold to the highest bidder at the Power County Courthouse in American Falls.
The Idaho State Journal explained the sale that morning in a feature by staff writer Paul Beebe. Its photograph showed the posted sale notices, and the caption named the Arbon Valley, Rockland and Holbrook country among the places where state ground was changing hands.
A grant from 1890
The land came to Idaho at statehood in 1890, when Congress granted the new state acreage whose earnings were meant for the public schools and a handful of other state institutions. For most of the next century the farm ground in those grants was leased rather than sold. The state had sold some land from its first years, Jim Mitchell, head of the Bureau of Lands in the state Department of Lands, told Beebe, but in the early 1900s the point was to draw settlers onto open country, and renting remained the usual way to handle cropland.
Arbon Valley had seen such sales before. In 1913, when the place was still called Bannock valley, a writer for the Boise Statesman told readers that state land there was on the market at an appraised $16 an acre, while privately deeded ground was generally priced around $20. The Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune reprinted the piece on August 9 of that year.
According to Mitchell, it was the State Land Board, the body over his department, that chose in 1975 to sell the farm ground outright. Five officials sat on it at the time: Governor Cecil Andrus, Secretary of State Pete Cenarrusa, Attorney General Wayne Kidwell, State Auditor Joe Williams and Superintendent of Public Instruction Roy Truby. Little was sold until 1980, when the department hired outside appraisers. The timber ground his office looked after was not for sale, he said.
Rid of a headache
The leases, Mitchell explained, had become more trouble than they were worth. Farmers who held them grumbled that a decade of the state’s rent cost too much. Others said the rent was far too cheap. Either way his office was left to manage the ground, and the board decided to sell “to get rid of the headache.” He was firm that Idaho’s present budget troubles had nothing to do with it. The counties stood to gain as well, since the law barred them from taxing state land, and each parcel that went private would join the property tax rolls.
Mitchell counted about 20,000 acres already in private hands by Wednesday, February 25, mostly in Power, Madison, Teton and Bonneville counties, and roughly 30,000 more would be offered before 1983, for about 50,000 acres statewide. He said no fiscal year in the state’s history would match this one for land sold.
Buyers were not hard to find. Most parcels had been appraised between $350 and $450 an acre, and none had sold for less. Ground that drew no bid at its appraised price stayed in state hands, to be reappraised or held until the market got better. Winning bids usually ran 20 to 30 percent over appraisal, and a few topped it by more than half. The state kept the mineral rights no matter who bought. Mitchell figured four buyers in five were farmers who had been leasing the very ground they bought, and he expected little of it to leave production. Some buyers lived out of state, though he did not say how many.
The money could not simply be spent. The state constitution forbids spending what the endowment land earns from sale or rent. Mitchell expected about $20 million from the sales, all of it bound for the Public School Endowment Fund, where only the interest could go toward the yearly operating costs of the schools and the other institutions. Over time, Beebe wrote, that might slow the climb of school taxes.
Five parcels at American Falls
The notice for the Power County sale had appeared in the Journal on February 8 and February 15 under the heading “State Land Sales.” First on the list was parcel 118-79, 120 acres of dry farmland in Arbon Valley some 25 miles southwest of Pocatello, appraised at $39,000, close to $325 an acre. The leaseholder would still be able to take off the 1981 crop. The biggest offering was a whole section, 640 acres, split into two units of 320 acres each. Both mixed dry farm with wasteland, one had some dry grazing as well, and they were appraised at $48,700 and $61,470. Rounding out the sale were 160 acres and 80 acres, both about 20 miles south of Pocatello. A buyer could put 10 percent down and pay the balance over 20 years at 10 percent interest, but bidders had to come to the courthouse in person or send an agent.
The results came out of Idaho Falls on March 8 from L. D. Benedick, the department’s area supervisor. Altogether the five units, roughly 1,000 acres, sold for $348,000.
Kenneth Estep of Pocatello paid $66,000 for the 120 acres, which the report located “in Arbon Valley near Pauline.” That came to $550 an acre, about 69 percent over the appraised price. The papers gave no legal description, so just where near Pauline the parcel lay is not known, nor who had been leasing it.
The full section, which the report put near Crystal, went to two Pocatello buyers. Mrs. Jean Wright bid $99,000 for the north half, and Elnora Wright bid $102,000 for the other unit. Between them they paid roughly 80 percent above the appraisals. Ralph Lusk of Arimo took the 160 acres near Rattlesnake Creek for $53,000, and Herman Krueger, also of Arimo, got the 80 acres for $28,000 after fifteen bidders went after it. More state land was to be auctioned the next week at Malad and again at American Falls. Whether any more of it lay in Arbon Valley, the pages read do not say.
Who bought
The papers printed only names and home towns. The Kenneth Estep who won the Pauline ground was most likely Ken Estep (1949–2021), whose parents were Luther and Eileen Ward Estep of Arbon. The Arbon Esteps descend from the valley’s Ward homesteaders. His 2021 obituary says that after college and a turn at professional bowling he spent some years in Pocatello selling insurance and advising clients on their finances before coming home to farm in Arbon full time. He went on to serve as a Power County commissioner and was honored at a farewell dinner in 2010.
Elnora Wright was probably Elnora Trullinger Wright, once a teacher at Crystal and the widow of Carl Wright of the Beuten and Wright ranch there. She was 88 that year and died two years later. Neither match is made in the papers themselves, which also leave unsaid how Jean Wright was connected to Elnora, if at all, and say nothing more of the two men from Arimo.
The state land was only part of the valley’s changing ownership in those years. Standard Oil had leased state ground there in 1949, and private farms were changing hands in the want ads of 1976 to 1983. In 1913 the state had asked $16 an acre for its valley land. Sixty-eight years later the Pauline ground brought $550 an acre, and every dollar went into a fund the schools can draw on only for its interest.