For the Christmas program of 1915, the pupils of a little school at Crystal carried their own desks out of the room so their families would have somewhere to sit. In their place went planks laid across chunks of wood. The teacher was Miss Agnes Burns, a few months out of high school, and the county school notes in the American Falls Press praised her nerve, confessing that the rest of the county’s teachers might never have managed it.
Nearly fifty years later, in September 1963, she was Mrs. Agnes Hartley of Rockland, one of seven retired teachers on a panel at the fall luncheon of Delta Kappa Gamma, an honor society for women in education. The Idaho State Journal gave her a single sentence. It said she had paid her own way through school, raised a family and kept teaching for many years while carrying the load of a ranch wife, and that her first classroom had been at Crystal, Idaho. The paper said nothing more about Crystal, but the Press had followed that first school closely, and it stood in the Crystal district of Arbon Valley.
Miss Burns of Rockland
Agnes Burns finished at American Falls High School with the class of May 1915. In July the Press reported her home again in Rockland, with two other young women of the town, after summer school at Albion. That same week she and Erma Sanders of Rockland were among eighteen candidates who wrote the teachers’ examination at the county superintendent’s office, and the paper expected most of them to take Power County schools that fall.
She was sent to Crystal, the high basin whose creeks drain into Bannock Creek. It made up School District 14, which covered roughly fifty square miles. Crystal Central School had gone up in 1912, but families on the edges of the district were served by smaller schools, and hers was in what the paper called the Thacker neighborhood. That November the county agent set up demonstrations of pea growing and of wintering hogs on several Crystal farms, Joe Thacker’s among them. None of the papers read for this story say where the schoolhouse itself stood, or what became of it.
A term in the Thacker neighborhood
On December 2, 1915, the school notes reported that Miss Burns, a 1915 graduate of the high school, was teaching “a successful term of school” there. Her honor roll for November attendance named Eddie, Ila and Josie Norton; James, Julian and Joseph Thacker; and George and Lottie Stewart. Several of those names are smudged in the newspaper scan, and Lottie’s is made out with the help of a later report. The same note mentioned that she had spent a recent weekend with her sister Bessie, who was in school at American Falls.
A week later the Arbon and Crystal teachers gathered at the Pauline meeting house. Miss Burns was there with the other Crystal teachers, Olive Beale and Lola Skartvedt, and it was Lola Skartvedt who told the meeting about the hot lunches at the Clifton Creek school. Then came the Christmas program on the plank benches, which the school notes summed up with an old saying: “Where there’s a will, there’s a way.”
Winter made travel hard. When she and Lola Skartvedt came down from the Crystal district for the county meetings of teachers and trustees at American Falls at the end of January 1916, the same report noted that the Roy teacher had needed a day and a half to get through the snow. In March she sent in another honor roll: Joseph and Julian Thacker and Lottie and George Stewart had not missed a day that month.
She did not return for a second year. By November 1916 the school notes placed a new teacher, V. O. Humphrey, in the Thacker neighborhood.
One of her pupils turned up in the paper again. In May 1921 the county superintendent ranked George Stewart of Crystal, the lone graduate listed from the Thacker school, first among that year’s eighth-grade graduates from the county’s district schools. He was very likely the same George Stewart whose name had appeared on her attendance rolls five years before.
Mrs. Will Hartley
In June 1917 the Press had a lighter item. William Hartley and Agnes Burns, newly married, stepped out of the Hotel Remington in American Falls just as the Chautauqua parade was breaking up. The band closed in around their car and would not stop playing until the cigars came out. By August the couple were “Mr. and Mrs. Will Hartley of Landing,” in the Rockland Valley over the hills to the west of Arbon Valley.
She went on teaching. In the spring of 1918 Mrs. Agnes Hartley had the Landing school, where her pupils started a garden club to earn money for war thrift stamps. The Hartleys had a daughter that July. In 1920 and again in 1921, her mother, Mrs. Agnes Burns of Nampa, came to stay for several weeks with her daughter at Landing, and it is those visits that connect the young teacher at Crystal with Mrs. Hartley of Rockland. In the fall of 1921 her name was back on the county’s list of rural teachers. How many years she taught after that, where she spent the 1916–17 term, and when and where she was born or died, the papers read here do not say.
The panel of 1963
The luncheon fell on a Saturday, probably September 14, and the seven panelists talked about what teaching had been like in their day. A month’s pay, they said, might run anywhere from $50 to $90, and country schools were glad to hire anyone who had finished the eighth grade.
Mrs. Hartley and Mrs. Thelma Sweet of American Falls sat with five Pocatello women: Mrs. Royal Brown, Agnes Asklof, Mrs. Hannah Sessions, Sylvia Smitham and Kathryn Burggraf. Mrs. Sessions, once Pocatello’s dean of girls, led the talk and read verse she had written in answer to the Second World War. Sylvia Smitham, for years a Latin teacher in Pocatello, read a poem of her own on why teaching was worth it. Agnes Asklof recalled the strict student-teaching rules Iowa set before it would certify her, before she moved to Idaho and taught at Wendell and Pocatello.
Kathryn Burggraf had first taught in Idaho at sixteen and retired in 1951. Going back to school in stretches, she earned degrees from the University of Washington and Stanford, and along the way she worked at the teachers’ college in Albion, as a state supervisor of education and as a county superintendent, and for fifteen years as an editorial and reading adviser to Houghton Mifflin. Mrs. Sweet had just retired from the business department at American Falls High School. Her typing workbook was used in Idaho schools and won the praise of the Gregg Publishing Co., and three times her students won a trip to Hollywood for their aviation education work. She and her husband were setting off on a long trailer trip around the country, to end with a winter in Florida.
Mrs. Brown had studied history and government at the University of Colorado and then did social work in Denver tied to Judge Ben B. Lindsey’s court. Her study of the West led to a master’s degree at the University of California and to several books, the best known being Fort Hall on the Oregon Trail. She had never set out to teach, yet she taught on college faculties in Minnesota and Idaho.
Beside careers like those, the paper’s one line about Mrs. Hartley was easy to pass over. The Press had already written the longer version, nearly half a century earlier, in a Crystal schoolroom so small that the desks had to go outside to make room for Christmas.
More on her first district is on the page for Crystal, along with the first schools at Crystal and the schools of Arbon Valley. Another valley teacher’s career is told in Lila Wade, teacher in Arbon’s one-room schools.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, September 19, 1963, page 20
- American Falls Press, May 27, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 22, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, July 29, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, November 11, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 2, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 23, 1915, page 6
- American Falls Press, January 6, 1916, page 2
- American Falls Press, February 3, 1916, page 3
- American Falls Press, March 23, 1916, page 6
- American Falls Press, November 2, 1916, page 12
- American Falls Press, June 12, 1917, page 5
- American Falls Press, August 28, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, April 2, 1918, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 30, 1918, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 9, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, December 17, 1920, page 4
- American Falls Press, January 7, 1921, page 2
- American Falls Press, April 8, 1921, page 5
- American Falls Press, May 27, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 16, 1921, page 5