In the fall of 1911, a month after their wedding, Jay and Marcena Whiting arrived at Crystal, the high basin over a low divide north of Pauline, to begin homesteading. Fifty years on, their twelve children invited everyone who knew them to a golden wedding reception in Pocatello.
The Idaho Sunday Journal carried the couple’s photograph on page 22 on Sunday, July 16, 1961. The party was set for 8 p.m. the following Saturday, July 22, at the Portneuf Grange Hall at Seventh and Sublette, with a program and a dance, and all of the couple’s friends and relatives were welcome. For readers who knew only the newer name, the paper explained that Crystal now lay in what was called Arbon Valley.
A Crystal family
Mr. L. A. Whiting was Lemuel Alma Whiting, though everyone called him Jay. He was born at Spanish Fork, Utah, on June 6, 1891, a son of Lorenzo Snow Whiting and Flora Waterman Whiting. In 1909 his father and two older brothers, Len and Forres, filed on homesteads in the Crystal basin, and the next year the family came over from Robin in Marsh Valley.
Jay married at Anaconda, Montana, on October 5, 1911, and he and his bride reached Crystal on November 7. Find a Grave gives her maiden name as Marcena Ames and her years as 1895 to 1980. In April 1915 the government patented 160 acres to Lemuel A. Whiting on the basin’s east side, in Sections 26 and 35 of Township 9 South, Range 34 East. Family records place the births of their first two children, Grace Geneva in 1912 and Arch Jay in 1914, in those Crystal years.
The country papers caught him at the everyday work of a young settlement. In December 1917 he gave toward the Crystal Christmas tree. That January he and Manning Standley were hauling Standley’s grain to Arimo, and by March he and Lawrence Evans were bringing in sawdust from “the old Whiting saw mill above George Bradley’s” for Ezra Lindsay’s store at Crystal. A baby arrived for Mr. and Mrs. L. A. Whiting on Sunday, May 5, 1918. In 1922 a party central committee picked him, with C. R. Butterfield and John Hayden, to judge the primary election in Crystal precinct, and a school column in November 1923 mentioned their five-year-old son Reece, whose name it spelled “Resse.”
Down to Pocatello
Jay left ahead of the rest of the Whitings. The American Falls Press gave his going one line on March 27, 1924: “L. A. Whiting and family moved to Pocatello.” It was the same winter the paper expected Crystal to be almost deserted. Later, when dry years and debt drove his brothers Len, Ralph and others to a ranch near Salmon, as told in Drought and debt empty Crystal and Buist, Jay kept his family in town.
He never quite let go of the hills. His younger brother, Alfred Reese Whiting, recalled in his memoir that in the summer of 1932 the two of them put up a sawmill on Crystal Creek, run by an old Avery steam engine the brothers had owned before. Reese cut the trees and Jay hauled the logs, with Jay’s daughter Juanita, about ten, pitching in. They swapped the lumber for goods, for scrip at a Pocatello store and for cows. Around 1934 Reese let Jay have his share of the mill and took his cows to Salmon.
Still at work at seventy
Neither half of the couple had retired by 1961. Jay kept the animals at the zoo in Ross Park, and the family made its home in the park itself; the paper did not say how long he had held the job. Marcena led the orchestra each week at the Golden Age Club, a Pocatello club for older people.
All twelve of their children were still living, and the family that had grown from Jay and Marcena now numbered 97. The paper expected most of the children to come, and many of the grandchildren with them. In Pocatello were A. J. Whiting, lately of Salmon; C. L. Whiting; Mr. and Mrs. Leon B. Whiting; Mr. and Mrs. Wally Wring; Mr. and Mrs. Nick DiViesti; Mr. and Mrs. Joseph King; and William Pierce. Farther off were Mr. and Mrs. Sterling A. Baier of St. John’s, British Columbia; Russell A. and Reece P. Whiting of Boerne, Texas; Mr. and Mrs. E. M. Hughes of Winton, California; and Boice Ames Whiting and his wife, with Boice on military duty in Formosa. Find a Grave lists six sons and six daughters, and most likely fit the paper’s list, the daughters under their husbands’ names, among them Mrs. Sterling A. Baier (Grace), Mrs. Wally Wring (Juanita) and Mrs. Joseph King (Shirley).
Two gatherings in one
A second notice just below the photograph showed that the anniversary was part of something larger. The descendants of Lorenzo (“Wren”) Snow Whiting Sr. and Flora Waterman Whiting held a reunion every year, and they had picked the same Saturday. Lorenzo had died at Crystal in 1920, the first person, and the only adult, laid to rest in the Crystal Ward’s cemetery, as told in the first burials at Crystal. Flora lived until 1949.
For the second summer in a row the clan would meet at Jay and Marcena’s house in the lower end of Ross Park. They planned a noon picnic and then the golden wedding, since one evening dance at the Grange hall would serve both crowds. On Sunday, July 23, the family would worship together on the Whiting lawn, then share a program and a luncheon before heading home.
No account of how the reception went has turned up in the papers searched for this post.
Jay Whiting died at Pocatello on April 6, 1973, and was buried at Restlawn. Four years later most of the graves in the little Crystal cemetery, his father’s among them, were moved to Restlawn too. More of the basin’s story is in the Crystal area history, in Crystal, the hidden settlement up Rattlesnake Creek, and in the account of Jay’s sister Ella, All of Crystal plants a widow’s grain. Father and son, who had both started out at Crystal, ended up in the same Pocatello ground.
Sources
- Idaho Sunday Journal, July 16, 1961, page 22
- American Falls Press, January 30, 1913, page 4
- American Falls Press, January 1, 1918, page 2
- American Falls Press, January 29, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, March 5, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, May 14, 1918, page 8
- American Falls Press, July 27, 1922, page 4
- American Falls Press, November 22, 1923, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 2
- Cash entry patent to Lemuel A. Whiting, April 17, 1915 (IDBL 0011104)
- Find a Grave, Lemuel Alma “Jay” Whiting (1891–1973)
- Alfred Reese Whiting, Life History (family memoir)